HOWTOWRITEAWORLDCLASSMETHODOLOGYPAPERElsevierAuthorWorkshopDateTitlePresenterName,Degree(s)TIPS,TRAPSANDTRAVESTIESOutline•Topublishornottopublish…•Writingaqualitymanuscript•Preparations•Articleconstruction•Language•Technicaldetails•Revisionsandresponsetoreviewers•Ethicalissues•Conclusions:gettingacceptedTopublishornottopublish…Whypublish?•Scientistspublishtosharewiththeresearchcommunityfindingsthatadvanceknowledgeandunderstanding•Topresentnew,originalresultsormethods•Torationalizepublishedresults•TopresentareviewofthefieldortosummarizeaparticulartopicPublishorperishFundingBodiesScientists/CliniciansGrantWritingJournalPublicationPublishersdonotwantzero-citedarticlesEditorsnowregularlyanalyzecitationsperarticle“Thestatisticthat27%ofourpaperswerenotcitedin5yearswasdisconcerting.Itcertainlyindicatesthatitisimportanttomaintainhighstandardswhenacceptingpapers...nothingwouldhavebeenlostexcepttheCV'softhoseauthorswouldhavebeenshorter…”–MarvBauer,Editor,RemoteSensingofEnvironmentPublishersdowantqualityWANTED•Originality•Significantadvancesinfield•Appropriatemethods,casestudiesandconclusions•Readability•StudiesthatmeetethicalstandardsNOTWANTED•Duplications•Reportsofnoscientificinterest•Workoutofdate•Inappropriate/incompletemethodsorconclusions•Studieswithinsufficientdata“Justbecauseithasnotbeendonebeforeisnojustificationfordoingitnow.”–PeterAttiwill,Editor-in-Chief,ForestEcologyandManagementCanIpublishthis?•Haveyoudonesomethingnewandinteresting?•Haveyoucheckedthelatestresultsinthefield?•Havethefindingsbeenverifiedbyappropriateanalysisandtheirsignificanceverified?•Arethemethods/measurementsvalidandreliable?•Canyoudescribethescopeandlimitationsofthemethods?•Doyourfindingstellanicestoryoristhestoryincomplete?•Istheworkdirectlyrelatedtoacurrenthottopic?•Haveyouprovidedsolutionstoanydifficultproblems?Ifallanswersare“yes”,thenstartpreparingyourmanuscript.Writingaqualitymanuscript•PreparationsWhattypeofmanuscript?FullLengthMethodologyRes...
