81/242A/INFForIECuseonly2004-08-13INTERNATIONALELECTROTECHNICALCOMMISSIONTECHNICALCOMMITTEENo.81:LIGHTNINGPROTECTIONRevisedcompilationofcommentson81/239/DC:IEC62305-1,Ed.1:Protectionagainstlightning-Part1:GeneralprinciplesCommentswereconsideredbyWG8atitsmeetinginJuly2004.___________________Thisdocumentcancelsandreplacesdocument81/242/INF.–2–81/242A/INFAnnexDateDocument2004-08-1381/239/DCNationalCommitteeClause/SubclauseParagraphFigure/TableTypeofcomment(General/Technical/Editorial)COMMENTSProposedchangeOBSERVATIONSOFTHESECRETARIAToneachcommentsubmittedDETheGermanNationalCommitteeagreeswithoutanycommentsNoted.ESTheSpanishNationalCommitteeacceptsthisdocumentassuchwithoutcommentsNoted.FR1ThepresentlayoutofbothIEC62305-3andIEC62305-4issatisfactory.ThereisnoreasontocombineIEC62305-3theAnnexBandIEC62305-4AnnexEtocombineitinIEC62305-1newAnnexE.KeepbothIEC62305-3andIEC62305-4textsastheyare.SeeIT1comment.GBTheUKnationalcommitteedoesnotagreetotheproposedchangesandbelievesthatthecurrentstructureofthe62305seriesismoreappropriateSeeIT1comment.IT1GeneralGeneralTheItalianNCisinfavourofanewAnnextoIEC62305-1relevanttothesurgesduedifferentsourcesofdamages.InthiswaytheAnnexwillcomplywiththescopeofIEC62305-1“Generalprinciples”.ThereforeinformationrelevanttorequirementsforSPDsshouldleaveinIEC62305-4.Agreed.IndeedmatterrelevanttolightningcurrentsduetodifferentsourcesofdamagebelongstothescopeofIEC62305-1,butmatterrelevanttorequirementsofSPDsbelongstoIEC62305-4andshouldleavethere.ThetextofAnnexEasagreedbyWG8isattached.LUEditorialWeaccepttheproposededitorialchangesasdescribedindocument81/239/DCNoted.NOTheNorwegianNCagreetotheproposalin81/239/DC1)todeleteinIEC62305-3theAnnexB(informative).2)todeleteinIEC62305-4theAnnexE(informative)and3)3)toaddtoIEC62305-1anewannexE(informative)Noted.–3–81/242A/INFNationalCommitteeClause/SubclauseParagraphFigure/TableTypeofcomment(General/Technical/Editorial)COMMENTSProposedchangeOBSERVATIONSOFTHESECRETARIAToneachcommentsubmittedPL1GeneralWegenerall...
